Internal Control · 2024
In this section9 topics
- Internal Control — Board Opinion1 item
- Adequacy & Appropriateness of the Internal Control System1 item
- Internal Control Deficiencies2 items
- Audit Committee & Auditor Observations3 items
- Opinion on the Head of Internal Audit2 items
- Appointment, Discharge & Transfer of the Head of Internal Audit2 items
- Related Party Transactions1 item
- Counterparties & Transactions3 items
- Policy & Future Trends2 items
Internal Control — Board Opinion
Summary of the Board's Opinion on Internal Control
The Board of Directors is of the opinion that the Company has established adequate and appropriate internal control systems and management. The management team has encouraged employees to recognize the importance of internal control and has allocated sufficient and suitable personnel to ensure that the Company's operations are conducted in accordance with its objectives, relevant laws and regulations, and good corporate governance principles effectively.
Furthermore, the Company has established an independent internal audit function to continuously monitor and evaluate the effectiveness of internal control. This is achieved by engaging an external independent internal audit firm (3rd Party) that reports directly to the Audit Committee on a quarterly basis.
Adequacy & Appropriateness of the Internal Control System
Internal Control Framework Used
| Framework | Detail |
|---|---|
| The Committee of Sponsoring Organizations of the Treadway Commission (COSO) | The Company recognizes and places importance on the establishment of an internal control system to comply with good corporate governance principles. At the Board of Directors' Meeting No. 2/2023 held on May 11, 2023, which was attended by 3 audit committee members, the Board of Directors considered and assessed the adequacy of the Company's internal control system according to the assessment form of the Securities and Exchange Commission, following the COSO (The Committee of Sponsoring Organizations of Treadway Commission) framework, by inquiring information from the management on 5 components, namely: 1) Control Environment 2) Risk Assessment 3) Control Activities 4) Information and Communication 5) Monitoring Activities |
Internal Control Deficiencies
Number of Deficiencies
| Metric | Current Year | Previous Year | Two Years Ago |
|---|---|---|---|
| Total number of internal control system deficiencies (cases) | 6 | 0 | 0 |
Deficiency Details
| Period Type | Start Period (YYYY-MM) | End Period (YYYY-MM) | Detail | Progress Status | Corrective Action |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| month/year Range | 2024-05 | 2024-05 | The HR department has implemented a "Personnel Request Form" for requesting personnel additions. However, there is no registration log for these forms, and the form itself lacks completeness in the following details:
- No Running Number
- No specification of the request date or desired start date
- In cases of replacement, the form does not specify which employee or department is being replaced.
- Upon successful recruitment, the name of the hired employee is not recorded on the Personnel Request Form. | Incident no longer subject to action | The "Annual Manpower Request Summary" form has been created, detailing the request number, request date, approval date, employee replacement name, recruitment date, start date, and employee name, etc. This form will be put into effect from June 1, 2023, onwards. |
| month/year Range | 2024-05 | 2024-05 | There are no interview scorecards used during the interview process to document the reasons for selecting a candidate. | Incident no longer subject to action | The "Interview Evaluation Form" has been implemented and used since July 1, 1964. |
| month/year Range | 2024-05 | 2024-05 | The HR department has training plans for 2023 and 2024. However, there is no comparison between the actual training conducted and the plan for 2023. As for 2024 (January to May), no training has been conducted yet. | Incident no longer subject to action | Started comparing actual training with the training plan, starting in 1984. |
| month/year Range | 2024-05 | 2024-05 | From the inspection of the work regulations regarding Training and Development (SP-HR-05), Revision 1, Effective Date October 12, 2023, and the actual practice, the following discrepancies with the regulations were found:
- No training evaluation forms for internal training.
- No training reports for training conducted with external institutions.
- No records of employee training history.
- No collection of certificates as proof of employee training completion. | Incident no longer subject to action | Commence the preparation of training reports for external training programs and record employee training history in the Training and Development Record Form for training conducted in 2024, starting from July 1, 2024, onwards. |
| month/year Range | 2024-05 | 2024-05 | From the data control inspection, employee history, Sales Order, and satisfaction surveys from related personnel, it was found that the "satisfaction survey," which obtained data from CRM staff conducting phone interviews with customers who had purchased products approximately 2-3 months prior and compiled into a report, was stored only on the CRM manager's notebook and not on the shared drive. Therefore, no data backup was performed. | Incident no longer subject to action | The CRM Manager has requested access to the shared drive for data storage. Completion date: June 4, 2023 (As per the document "Application for Access Rights and Cancellation of Information System Users" submitted) |
| month/year Range | 2024-05 | 2024-05 | Based on the review of the Restore Backup test results from INET's Business Continuity Plan document, it was found that the restore testing intervals do not comply with the "Backup and Recovery Procedure (SP-IT-03)", which requires backup restore testing every 6 months. The actual backup restore test results for INET are as follows:
- Test 1: October 20, 2022
- Test 2: May 30, 2023 (7 months after Test 1)
- Test 3: February 16, 2024 (9 months after Test 2) | Incident no longer subject to action | INET and the Company have completed the backup restoration within the timeframe specified in the plan. |
Audit Committee & Auditor Observations
Introduction
Opinion on the Internal Control System of the Board of Directors
The Board of Directors is of the opinion that the Company has adequate and appropriate internal control and management systems. The management has encouraged employees in the organization to recognize the importance of internal control and has provided adequate and appropriate personnel to ensure that the Company's operations are carried out in accordance with the objectives and in compliance with relevant laws and regulations, and in accordance with good corporate governance principles effectively.
In addition, the Company has an independent internal audit function to continuously monitor and evaluate internal control by hiring an internal auditor, which is an independent third party, to report directly to the Audit Committee on a quarterly basis.
Auditor's Observation
Siam Truth Accounting Co., Ltd., the Company's auditor, approved by the SEC, has audited the effectiveness of the Company's internal control over financial reporting for the purpose of determining the scope of the audit to be rigorous and appropriate. From the audit of the Company's financial statements for the year ended December 31, 2024, the auditor has no significant findings on the Company's internal control system.
Audit Committee's Opinion Differs from the Board's
No
Auditor Has Observations on Internal Control
No
Opinion on the Head of Internal Audit
Head of Internal Audit
3160
Audit Committee's Opinion on the Head of Internal Audit
The Audit Committee has considered the qualifications of BKIA & IC Co., Ltd. as the Company's internal auditor for the year 2023 and has appointed Ms. Bunnee Kusonsopit as the Head of Internal Audit, considering that she has adequate education, experience, and training to perform the duties of the Company's internal auditor, as well as independence in performing her duties to audit and assess the adequacy of the internal control system and compliance with the Company's systems. The internal auditor has coordinated with personnel from all departments of the Company, followed up on improvements to the internal control system in accordance with the recommendations of the internal auditor, including preparing an internal control assessment and audit report of the Company, and presenting the report directly to the Audit Committee on a regular basis. (Details of the qualifications of the Head of Internal Audit are provided in Annex 3 "Details of the Head of Internal Audit")
Appointment, Discharge & Transfer of the Head of Internal Audit
Requires Audit Committee Approval
Yes
Description
The Audit Committee has considered the qualifications of BKIA & IC Co., Ltd. as the Company's internal auditor for 2023 and has appointed Ms. Boonnee Gusonsopit as the Head of Internal Audit, considering that she has sufficient qualifications, experience, and training to perform the duties of the Company's internal auditor, as well as independence in performing her duties to audit and assess the adequacy of the internal control system and compliance with the Company's systems. The internal auditor has coordinated with personnel from all departments of the Company, monitored the improvement of the internal control system to comply with the recommendations of the internal auditor, including preparing an assessment report and auditing the Company's internal control system, and presenting the report to the Audit Committee meetings directly on a regular basis. (Details of the qualifications of the Head of Internal Audit are shown in Annex 3 "Details of the Head of Internal Audit")
According to the Audit Committee Charter, the Audit Committee has the power, duties, and responsibilities to review and advise the Company on the adequacy and effectiveness of the internal control and internal audit systems, consider the independence of the internal audit function, as well as provide recommendations for the approval, appointment, removal, and transfer of the Head of Internal Audit or any other unit responsible for internal audit.
Related Party Transactions
Has Related Party Transactions
Yes
Counterparties & Transactions
Monetary Unit
1
Counterparties with Potential Conflicts
| Name | Person / Juristic Person | Type of Business | Nature of Relationship | As of Date (YYYY-MM-DD) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Retail Business Solutions Co., Ltd. | Juristic Person | The business sells household furniture, specializing in various shelves. | • Mr. Noppol Chuglin, a director, authorized signatory, and major shareholder of RBS, holding 98.09 percent of the shares. • Mr. Noppol Chuglin, a director, Chairman of the Nomination and Remuneration Committee, Chairman of the Risk Management Committee, and Chairman of the Executive Committee of the Company. | 2024-12-31T00:00 |
| New Progress (Thailand) Co., Ltd. | Juristic Person | Originally engaged in telemarketing, the business has now transitioned into a restaurant and catering service. | • Previously, Mr. Saran Vajasupharb was a shareholder of New Progress, holding 40.00 percent of the shares on June 27, 2022. • Mr. Saran has sold all of his shares in New Progress to unrelated individuals. Currently, he is not a shareholder and has no involvement in the company. | 2024-12-31T00:00 |
| Sarun Vachasuphaprab | Person | Mr. Saran, who is the Chief Executive Officer, Director, Executive Director, Authorized Director, and major shareholder of the company, holding 50.56 percent of shares. | 2024-12-31T00:00 |
Transactions by Counterparty
| Transactions |
|---|
| 101200.0 · Necessity: The company procured desks from Retail Business Solutions Co., Ltd. for installation at the temporary office located at Samut Prakan Prison (2022), Chiang Mai Women's Correctional Institution, and Chonburi Women's Correctional Institution (2023). Additional transportation costs for installation will be incurred. The purchase is currently under payment schedule, resulting in outstanding expenses. In 2024, there was an asset purchase transaction that included transportation costs. The company ordered office desks from Retail Business Solutions Co., Ltd. to be installed and used at Chonburi Prison. This expenditure is considered a normal operating expense of the company. The company considered procuring these assets from other vendors but found that Retail Business Solutions Co., Ltd. (RBS) offered a more competitive price and comparable sales terms. · Description: Purchase a desk Desk delivery fee Consultation fee · As of yesteryear: 419220.0 · Nature of transaction: Purchase of assets Additional transportation charges Selling and administrative expenses · Audit committee opinion: The Board of Directors has reviewed and deemed the aforementioned list reasonable and beneficial to the company's business operations. Furthermore, the company's service charges, pricing, and terms of service adhere to the company's established procedures and guidelines, and are subject to the same commercial terms applied to other customers. · As of year before yesteryear: 140380.0 · 0.0 · Necessity: The purchase of assets is currently being paid for in installments, resulting in expenses. · Description: List of pending purchase orders · As of yesteryear: 236384.0 · Nature of transaction: Accrued expenses · Audit committee opinion: The Board of Directors has reviewed and deemed the aforementioned items reasonable and beneficial to the company's business operations. · As of year before yesteryear: 159815.0 |
| 0.0 · Necessity: The Company was engaged by New Progress (Thailand) Co., Ltd. under a sales management service agreement. · Description: Service Income-Market · As of yesteryear: 0.0 · Nature of transaction: Other Income · Audit committee opinion: The Audit Committee has reviewed and deemed the aforementioned list to be reasonable and justifiable. Additionally, the prices are consistent with those offered to other customers and are accompanied by appropriate commercial terms. · As of year before yesteryear: 75000.0 · 0.0 · Necessity: Please provide the context or specify what you would like to know about the price list for marketing submissions. The information provided only states that it's the same price as other customers with general trading conditions. · Description: Sales Promotion Fee · As of yesteryear: 0.0 · Nature of transaction: Selling and Administrative Expenses · Audit committee opinion: The Audit Committee has reviewed and deemed the aforementioned list to be reasonable and justifiable. Furthermore, the prices are consistent with those offered to other customers and are accompanied by appropriate commercial terms. · As of year before yesteryear: 999396.28 |
| 0.0 · Necessity: The company entered into a car rental agreement with Mr. Saran Wetsupaporn for use as an executive car with a monthly rental fee of 60,000 baht. The company considered rental fees from other vendors, and the agreed-upon rate is in line with those offered by other vendors during the same period. The company rented the car until August 2022 and terminated the rental agreement in September 2022. Regarding executive compensation in 2022, payments were made to executives who worked for the company as per the resolution of the Annual General Meeting of Shareholders on April 30, 2021, with a total amount not exceeding 1.50 million baht. · Description: Car rental fees Executive compensation · As of yesteryear: 0.0 · Nature of transaction: Selling and administrative expenses · Audit committee opinion: The committee has reviewed and deemed the list to be reasonable. Regarding car rental fees, a price comparison has been conducted, confirming that the proposed rental rates are in line with those offered by other vendors. · As of year before yesteryear: 480000.0 |
Policy & Future Trends
Policy, Measures & Approval Process
The Company recognizes its duty to comply with the regulations on intercompany transactions or connected transactions as prescribed by the Stock Exchange of Thailand, the Securities and Exchange Commission, and the Office of the Securities and Exchange Commission. The Company has approved the Intercompany Transactions Policy at the Meeting of the Board of Directors (Company Limited) No. 1/2023 on October 19, 2023, which sets out the following principles and procedures for intercompany transactions or connected transactions:
Under the implementation of laws and regulations related to connected transactions, the Company has established measures and procedures for intercompany transactions as follows:
1. In considering intercompany transactions, the Company shall apply the same criteria as for general customers and/or the general public, including following the Company's normal operating procedures to support business operations, which must be fair, reasonable, and in the best interests of the Company.
2. In the event that there is no such price, the Company will consider comparing the price of goods or services with external prices under the same or similar conditions.
3. The Company may utilize the reports of independent appraisers on the SEC's list, appointed by the Company, to compare prices for significant intercompany transactions to ensure that such prices are reasonable and in the best interests of the Company.
4. Intercompany transactions of the Company in which directors, executives, or persons who may have a conflict of interest or related benefits, that are not ordinary course of business transactions or have different commercial terms from transactions with general customers or external parties, may be carried out only upon approval by a majority vote of the Board of Directors' Meeting. No directors, executives, or persons who may have a conflict of interest or related benefits shall participate in the consideration and approval of such transactions. There shall be no unusual or special conditions or terms, in accordance with the criteria set by the Company. However, if such matters require the approval of the Shareholders' Meeting, the relevant rules and regulations shall be followed.
5. If the Company has other intercompany transactions that fall under the notification requirements of the Stock Exchange of Thailand and/or the SEC, it must strictly comply with such requirements.
6. The Company must disclose information on transactions that may involve conflicts of interest or intercompany transactions in accordance with the regulations of the Securities and Exchange Commission, the Stock Exchange of Thailand, and/or relevant agencies, and in accordance with generally accepted accounting principles, by disclosing such information in the annual registration statement, annual report, or other reports, as the case may be.
7. To have an audit of intercompany transactions according to the audit plan by the Internal Audit Department, which must report to the Audit Committee, and have control measures, monitoring, and supervision to ensure random audits of irregularities in the actual transactions, in accordance with the agreements, policies, or conditions set forth.
8. The Audit Committee shall consider, review, and approve intercompany transactions and report the results of the review to the Board of Directors according to the financial reporting cycle.
Future Trends in Related Party Transactions
In the event of future connected transactions, the Company will comply with the Company's Articles of Association, the Securities and Exchange Act, the regulations, notifications, orders, or requirements of the Securities and Exchange Commission, the Capital Market Supervisory Board, and the Stock Exchange of Thailand, or the requirements for disclosure of connected transactions as prescribed under such regulations, notifications, orders, or requirements, including financial reporting standards prescribed by the Federation of Accounting Professions and other relevant regulations. Such transactions must not constitute a transfer or diversion of the Company's benefits. The transactions must be in the best interests of the Company and all shareholders.
Interested persons shall not be entitled to vote on matters relating to such transactions in the case of ordinary course of business transactions or transactions in support of ordinary course of business, and transactions that occur on a recurring basis in the future. The Company has established guidelines and procedures to ensure that the transactions are conducted in accordance with arm's length principles, based on appropriate and fair prices and conditions, are reasonable, verifiable, and presented to the Audit Committee for its opinion and the Board of Directors for approval as a framework for such transactions by the management. The Company shall compile and prepare a summary report of such transactions for reporting at the Audit Committee meetings and the Board of Directors meetings every quarter.
